Offline
I guess by now everyone has seen the video of a NY police officer dressed in plain clothes, tackling and slamming James Blake (former tennis star) to the ground on Wednesday. But for those who haven't seen or heard about it -- Mr. Blake was just standing in front of a hotel using his cell while waiting for a ride. Out of nowhere a man wearing shorts and a tee shirt, ran up to him without identifying himself or asking any questions of Mr. Blake, and tackled him. Mr. Blake was slammed down face forward and cuffed. Five other officers arrived on the scene and one of them recognized James Blake. Police Commissioner, Bill Bratton, apologized and ordered internal affairs to open an investigation The officer who attacked him has not apologized but is now on desk duty. They claim it was a case of mistaken identity. But nobody talked to him or even showed a badge. At first it sounded like James Blake was going to just let it go, but I heard he might seek a financial donation from the city for a worthy cause. He said he has the resources and a platform that most citizens don't have to call attention to these things and this happens to people every day. I'm glad he is speaking out and I wish he would sue the pants off them. This has got to stop.
Any thoughts fellow posters?
Offline
Thanks for posting this ,Sara! I havent heard anything about this! Im gald hes taking that approach,hes right some dont have the voice he has!I firmly believe until these cities have to pay out the big money ,They arent going to care! Money is power,I know many dont agree ,but we see it every day when we have to deal with the sideshow of The Donald! These police depts will get rid of these cops if they cost them money!When you stand by and look at the abusive cops and Trump,we really need to be worried about where this country is going! REALLY Worried! Instead of Heil Hilter ,It will be Heil Trump!.with cops walking down the streets ,busting into your homes etc----Oh wait Cops are already doing that!
Last edited by Dori (9/12/2015 8:57 am)
Offline
It's out of hand. What will it take for real change to happen?
Offline
I like that Blake is speaking out and that he is not after money but actual changes.
Offline
I saw the video clip on CNN this morning...totally horrifying....
One second, he's standing there leaning against the building, looked like he was texting on his phone....and suddenly this big guy runs over, grabs him and throws him down on the ground, face down, with this persons' knee pressed against his lower spine....He didn't have time to resist.....I couldn't believe my eyes.......
Offline
AdminShiny wrote:
I like that Blake is speaking out and that he is not after money but actual changes.
Me too, Shiny. This has gone too far...James Blake is far too pretty to be thrown around like that . They need to tackle Trump!
Offline
Zurich Moon wrote:
AdminShiny wrote:
I like that Blake is speaking out and that he is not after money but actual changes.
Me too, Shiny. This has gone too far...James Blake is far too pretty to be thrown around like that . They need to tackle Trump!
Lol!........wait you remind me of someone????.....are you zeke????...lol....BTW where is zeke?
And you're right they need to tackle DT,,,face down!
Offline
Spunky wrote:
Zurich Moon wrote:
AdminShiny wrote:
I like that Blake is speaking out and that he is not after money but actual changes.
Me too, Shiny. This has gone too far...James Blake is far too pretty to be thrown around like that . They need to tackle Trump!
Lol!........wait you remind me of someone????.....are you zeke????...lol....BTW where is zeke?
And you're right they need to tackle DT,,,face down!
Spuinky, you crack me up! I was just over here HOWLING at one of your other posts ! I love how you roll ! Now, keep this just between us...I'm Zeke on Mon, Wed and Fri .
I'm telling you, if they had messed up James Blake's face I would have organized a march on NYC! That is a gorgeous man, who also happens to be intelligent and talented, but others can marvel at those insignificant attributes...did I mention how pretty he is? As far as Frump goes, it is hilarious that he feels justified in making disparaging remarks about other people's physical appearance. Don't know about any of you fine folks, but I have yet to gaze over at my husband and think "if only he looked like Donald Trump..."
Offline
Zurich Moon wrote:
Spunky wrote:
Zurich Moon wrote:
Me too, Shiny. This has gone too far...James Blake is far too pretty to be thrown around like that . They need to tackle Trump!Lol!........wait you remind me of someone????.....are you zeke????...lol....BTW where is zeke?
And you're right they need to tackle DT,,,face down!
Spuinky, you crack me up! I was just over here HOWLING at one of your other posts ! I love how you roll ! Now, keep this just between us...I'm Zeke on Mon, Wed and Fri .
I'm telling you, if they had messed up James Blake's face I would have organized a march on NYC! That is a gorgeous man, who also happens to be intelligent and talented, but others can marvel at those insignificant attributes...did I mention how pretty he is? As far as Frump goes, it is hilarious that he feels justified in making disparaging remarks about other people's physical appearance. Don't know about any of you fine folks, but I have yet to gaze over at my husband and think "if only he looked like Donald Trump..."
Spunky and Zurich Tied for the Honor of making me spew perfectly good bottled water over a perfectly crappy keyboard!!
Offline
You people crack me up! As for the latest incident, they picked on the wrong man this time, let them make up excuses and try to blame him for everything, they've already said he was a dead ringer for the real person they were looking for, like that makes it alright the way they handled it, guilty until proven innocent. I'm sure the bad cop enablers are still working hard to keep things covered up.
Offline
NESunrise wrote:
Zurich Moon wrote:
Spunky wrote:
Lol!........wait you remind me of someone????.....are you zeke????...lol....BTW where is zeke?
And you're right they need to tackle DT,,,face down!
Spuinky, you crack me up! I was just over here HOWLING at one of your other posts ! I love how you roll ! Now, keep this just between us...I'm Zeke on Mon, Wed and Fri .
I'm telling you, if they had messed up James Blake's face I would have organized a march on NYC! That is a gorgeous man, who also happens to be intelligent and talented, but others can marvel at those insignificant attributes...did I mention how pretty he is? As far as Frump goes, it is hilarious that he feels justified in making disparaging remarks about other people's physical appearance. Don't know about any of you fine folks, but I have yet to gaze over at my husband and think "if only he looked like Donald Trump..."
Spunky and Zurich Tied for the Honor of making me spew perfectly good bottled water over a perfectly crappy keyboard!!
Sorry about that, NE! I'm glad we entertained you for a bit !
Offline
teluog wrote:
You people crack me up! As for the latest incident, they picked on the wrong man this time, let them make up excuses and try to blame him for everything, they've already said he was a dead ringer for the real person they were looking for, like that makes it alright the way they handled it, guilty until proven innocent. I'm sure the bad cop enablers are still working hard to keep things covered up.
It's such a shame because there are so many great cops who are excellent at what they do. But as far as I am concerned, this cop should be at Gitmo being waterboarded for nearly damaging THAT face! Yes, it is that serious!
Offline
NESunrise wrote:
Zurich Moon wrote:
Spunky wrote:
Lol!........wait you remind me of someone????.....are you zeke????...lol....BTW where is zeke?
And you're right they need to tackle DT,,,face down!
Spuinky, you crack me up! I was just over here HOWLING at one of your other posts ! I love how you roll ! Now, keep this just between us...I'm Zeke on Mon, Wed and Fri .
I'm telling you, if they had messed up James Blake's face I would have organized a march on NYC! That is a gorgeous man, who also happens to be intelligent and talented, but others can marvel at those insignificant attributes...did I mention how pretty he is? As far as Frump goes, it is hilarious that he feels justified in making disparaging remarks about other people's physical appearance. Don't know about any of you fine folks, but I have yet to gaze over at my husband and think "if only he looked like Donald Trump..."
Spunky and Zurich Tied for the Honor of making me spew perfectly good bottled water over a perfectly crappy keyboard!!
Well...thank you for the compliment!..Our aim is to 'keep' everyone smiling...wait...did I just say 'keep' ugg!
Try to have a nice day everyone even if I used that dreadful word 'keep'...sorry
Offline
Zurich Moon wrote:
AdminShiny wrote:
I like that Blake is speaking out and that he is not after money but actual changes.
Me too, Shiny. This has gone too far...James Blake is far too pretty to be thrown around like that . They need to tackle Trump!
I'm sure James Blake did not see the humor in this situation. Or, any of the other unarmed innocent men who have ended up dead because of the actions of hot headed police officers.
Offline
SaraG wrote:
Zurich Moon wrote:
AdminShiny wrote:
I like that Blake is speaking out and that he is not after money but actual changes.
Me too, Shiny. This has gone too far...James Blake is far too pretty to be thrown around like that . They need to tackle Trump!
I'm sure James Blake did not see the humor in this situation. Or, any of the other unarmed innocent men who have ended up dead because of the actions of hot headed police officers.
Thank goodness reasonable people can make the distinction between laughing at a silly (but serious) lust for James Blake (with his pretty self), and laughing at the abuse or killing of innocent young men
Offline
Spunky wrote:
NESunrise wrote:
Zurich Moon wrote:
Spunky and Zurich Tied for the Honor of making me spew perfectly good bottled water over a perfectly crappy keyboard!!
Well...thank you for the compliment!..Our aim is to 'keep' everyone smiling...wait...did I just say 'keep' ugg!
Try to have a nice day everyone even if I used that dreadful word 'keep'...sorry
Offline
Hello,
There are many posters that know I am from a family of law enforcement professionals. Please allow me to speak from this perspective and with much experience.
I am aware of the James Blake situation and have an opinion. First, what if this was the suspect officer Frascatore was looking for and not James Blake? Would it have been a good arrest on the part of undercover officer Frascatore and would we praise him for this? I think yes.
Did Frascatore use excessive force? No, I don't think he did. Thrown to the ground, face down and knee pressed against the lower spine is common police tactic to apprehend. Again, if this was the suspect Frascatore was pursuing what should he have done? Say "Hello I am an undercover police officer, may I arrest you?" Come on now. Granted Blake was mistakenly taken for the suspect, even though he was a "dead ringer", but all worked out in the end and even Blake said he was not hurt.
Police work is more difficult than it looks. It is common for crime suspects to resist arrest and the officer needs to be prepared. If a tragedy occurs during confrontation, people are quick to assume police brutality. There are complexities and dangers involved when officers are faced with quick decisions when making an arrest. In this case Blake was not the suspect and did not resist allowing officer Frascatore to reevaluate and Blake was not hurt.
It happens sometimes but what if Blake was the suspect? IMO officer Frascatore did nothing wrong, he was doing his job. This is not in defence of the "bad cop" which does exist but not in this particular case imo.
Offline
Braveone99 wrote:
Hello,
There are many posters that know I am from a family of law enforcement professionals. Please allow me to speak from this perspective and with much experience.
I am aware of the James Blake situation and have an opinion. First, what if this was the suspect officer Frascatore was looking for and not James Blake? Would it have been a good arrest on the part of undercover officer Frascatore and would we praise him for this? I think yes.
Did Frascatore use excessive force? No, I don't think he did. Thrown to the ground, face down and knee pressed against the lower spine is common police tactic to apprehend. Again, if this was the suspect Frascatore was pursuing what should he have done? Say "Hello I am an undercover police officer, may I arrest you?" Come on now. Granted Blake was mistakenly taken for the suspect, even though he was a "dead ringer", but all worked out in the end and even Blake said he was not hurt.
Police work is more difficult than it looks. It is common for crime suspects to resist arrest and the officer needs to be prepared. If a tragedy occurs during confrontation, people are quick to assume police brutality. There are complexities and dangers involved when officers are faced with quick decisions when making an arrest. In this case Blake was not the suspect and did not resist allowing officer Frascatore to reevaluate and Blake was not hurt.
It happens sometimes but what if Blake was the suspect? IMO officer Frascatore did nothing wrong, he was doing his job. This is not in defence of the "bad cop" which does exist but not in this particular case imo.
In this instance, I agree that the officer did not use excessive force (assuming he identified himself as an undercover cop in a timely manner.) Having seen the photo of the suspect, I can understand how he would be mistaken for my beloved James. Unfortunately, a lot of good cops are paying a huge price for all of the bad cops who have gotten away with murder, both literally and figuratively, over time. With the advent of the cell phone vids, the arrogance, corruption and racism long associated with law enforcement can no longer be denied. This leaves us in a very scary place...with the rash of senseless cop killings, the police are going to be more on edge and more aggressive, understandably so. With the viral videos we have seen of innocent citizens being slaughtered at the hands of cops, the people fear for their lives and are more prone to resist arrest. I don't know the solution, but a good place to start is to eliminate bad cops when they are exposed without excuses or hesitation. This matter will never get better until the people can trust their law enforcement to serve and protect them honorably. Won't happen overnight but it's time to start.
Offline
Zurich Moon wrote:
Braveone99 wrote:
Hello,
There are many posters that know I am from a family of law enforcement professionals. Please allow me to speak from this perspective and with much experience.
I am aware of the James Blake situation and have an opinion. First, what if this was the suspect officer Frascatore was looking for and not James Blake? Would it have been a good arrest on the part of undercover officer Frascatore and would we praise him for this? I think yes.
Did Frascatore use excessive force? No, I don't think he did. Thrown to the ground, face down and knee pressed against the lower spine is common police tactic to apprehend. Again, if this was the suspect Frascatore was pursuing what should he have done? Say "Hello I am an undercover police officer, may I arrest you?" Come on now. Granted Blake was mistakenly taken for the suspect, even though he was a "dead ringer", but all worked out in the end and even Blake said he was not hurt.
Police work is more difficult than it looks. It is common for crime suspects to resist arrest and the officer needs to be prepared. If a tragedy occurs during confrontation, people are quick to assume police brutality. There are complexities and dangers involved when officers are faced with quick decisions when making an arrest. In this case Blake was not the suspect and did not resist allowing officer Frascatore to reevaluate and Blake was not hurt.
It happens sometimes but what if Blake was the suspect? IMO officer Frascatore did nothing wrong, he was doing his job. This is not in defence of the "bad cop" which does exist but not in this particular case imo.
In this instance, I agree that the officer did not use excessive force (assuming he identified himself as an undercover cop in a timely manner.) Having seen the photo of the suspect, I can understand how he would be mistaken for my beloved James. Unfortunately, a lot of good cops are paying a huge price for all of the bad cops who have gotten away with murder, both literally and figuratively, over time. With the advent of the cell phone vids, the arrogance, corruption and racism long associated with law enforcement can no longer be denied. This leaves us in a very scary place...with the rash of senseless cop killings, the police are going to be more on edge and more aggressive, understandably so. With the viral videos we have seen of innocent citizens being slaughtered at the hands of cops, the people fear for their lives and are more prone to resist arrest. I don't know the solution, but a good place to start is to eliminate bad cops when they are exposed without excuses or hesitation. This matter will never get better until the people can trust their law enforcement to serve and protect them honorably. Won't happen overnight but it's time to start.
Hi Zurich,
Thanks for your response.
Expecting an undercover cop to identify him or her self defeats the whole purpose of undercover. Wouldn't you agree?
You are right, many good cops are being scrutinized because of bad cops. Not necessarily a bad thing imo. I can tell you with confidence that the majority of cops are good and are as upset as the citizens to acknowledge the bad cops. Many officers police themselves and take action against those disgracing the badge, sometimes quietly but very effective.
Citizens need to gain back their trust in law enforcement to honorably serve and protect. The solution is complex for sure. A good beginning is community policing with more "boots on the ground" and talking with the neighborhood leaders and every day citizens. I happen to live and work in a community that has dedicated resources to make this happen. So far, so good! It doesn't take much to drop a dime on a criminal or "bad cop".
Won't happen overnight but, as you say, it is time to start. Stories blown out of proportion like with your beloved James don't help. BTW, his face is kickass gorgeous and thankfully still intact.
Offline
Braveone99 wrote:
Hello,
There are many posters that know I am from a family of law enforcement professionals. Please allow me to speak from this perspective and with much experience.
I am aware of the James Blake situation and have an opinion. First, what if this was the suspect officer Frascatore was looking for and not James Blake? Would it have been a good arrest on the part of undercover officer Frascatore and would we praise him for this? I think yes.
Did Frascatore use excessive force? No, I don't think he did. Thrown to the ground, face down and knee pressed against the lower spine is common police tactic to apprehend. Again, if this was the suspect Frascatore was pursuing what should he have done? Say "Hello I am an undercover police officer, may I arrest you?" Come on now. Granted Blake was mistakenly taken for the suspect, even though he was a "dead ringer", but all worked out in the end and even Blake said he was not hurt.
Police work is more difficult than it looks. It is common for crime suspects to resist arrest and the officer needs to be prepared. If a tragedy occurs during confrontation, people are quick to assume police brutality. There are complexities and dangers involved when officers are faced with quick decisions when making an arrest. In this case Blake was not the suspect and did not resist allowing officer Frascatore to reevaluate and Blake was not hurt.
It happens sometimes but what if Blake was the suspect? IMO officer Frascatore did nothing wrong, he was doing his job. This is not in defence of the "bad cop" which does exist but not in this particular case imo.
Braveone, I have police officers in my family also, including a retired police chief. A big question is this, if the officers felt they did the right thing, why didn't they report it to their superiors? The police commissioner, Bill Bratton, said they did not report it. You may feel it is acceptable for a cop to run up and tackle someone they suspect is a criminal, but that is not how our system works. Citizens should be able to stand on a street without a policeman attacking them. The officer did not identify himself. Even if James Blake had been the person they were looking for, it is still improper procedure. Laws are in place for a reason. It is time cops start recognizing they are to follow the laws also. Their job is to serve and protect, not attack and ask questions later.
Edited to add: This cop has other charges against him for excessive force.in other incidents. He punched a guy in the mouth several times and another person in the stomach and each time used racial slurs.
Last edited by SaraG (9/13/2015 10:58 pm)